
Are you still waffling over whether or not you should hug your big ol' original DS goodbye and pick up a DS Lite? We know some of you are still clinging to the old ways, but never fear -- we're here to help! This week, we're going to look at ten reasons to make the switch ... and ten reasons to stick with what you've got. Oh, we never said we'd make the decision easy.
Of course, the minute we convince you, Nintendo's apt to completely redesign the hardware all over again! But don't worry -- you'll be armed with a list of reasons to wait on anything new ... at least, until we decide to start convincing you to upgrade again. It's the circle of Nintenfandom; you know you're used to it by now.
Ten reasons to upgrade to a Lite (in no particular order):
1. Weight
The DS Lite is more than 20% lighter (liter?) than the original model, which means you can hold it that much longer during intense play sessions without your hands and wrists screaming for mercy. If that's not an improvement, we don't know what is! Maybe if it also cooked you up some popcorn during play ... that would be pretty awesome.
2. Size
For some gamers, this might not actually be a benefit, but for those of us who don't have giant man hands of epic proportions, the DS Lite rests a little more comfortably in our mitts. Further, the DS Lite slips more easily into a pocket, which is always a plus if you find yourself sans case. And speaking of cases ....
3. Case selection
There are tons of excellent cases, from cheap to super snazzy, that only work for the Lite. Trying to squeeze the Phat model in there can get ugly fast; it's like Cinderella's stepsisters hacking off toes in their attempt to fit into the glass slipper, only with the blood and knives replaced with tears, voided warranties, and possible electrocution.
4. Other accessories
It's not just cases, though -- there's a bevy of neat accessories out there that are sized for the DS Lite only. Who can say no to a bendy stand? That would certainly be useful for those power sessions of Puzzle Quest or Clubhouse Games that make the ol' back and neck squeal from hours of hovering directly over the screen. Or you can always stick it somewhere -- to somewhere metal, that is. Who says you need Cooking Navi to display your DS on the fridge? Think outside the recipe box!

Okay, we admit it -- the Lite is just plain hot. It looks good, it feels good, and it's 15% slicker than the original model (note: we completely made up that statistic). We don't think the new design is enough of a reason on its own for anyone to shell out the bucks -- unless you just think it's irresistible -- but luckily, it's not the only reason to finally make the jump.
6. Availability
Here's something practical to combat the rather frivolous preceding reason -- the accessories, cases, and other items we mentioned about tend to be more readily available in their Liter forms. It's not all about the extras, though; even the recent browser, which is available in two versions, is a lot easier to find for the Lite.
7. Improved battery life
This is definitely an advantage if, like us, you tend to settle down for long sessions of play. It's even more imperative if other people around you tend to hijack your DS (we keep thinking about setting up some sort of alarm system) and never think to charge it for you. For the same amount of quality time with the charger, you can get several hours more play out of your Lite. Since we don't like to be tied down to the charger very often, that is a major benefit.
8. Brighter screens
This is both an advantage and a caution. The brighter, adjustable screens on the Lite offer a nice range of customization, but if you tend to prefer the brightest settings, this one may cancel out the preceding reason. We recommend a less eye-searing setting in order to take advantage of that battery ... but isn't it nice to know that you have options?
9. Doubling your DS load
If you upgrade and keep your original DS (which we think tends to be better than turning it in for a measly amount of store credit), then you now have double the DS power you had before. This means you can strongarm people who don't have their own DS into playing with you, thanks to all the games that allow multiplayer from a single cart. Once you get them started, of course, nearly anyone will be hooked on at least a few games -- and you've just finagled yourself a new playing partner, all because you happened to have that extra DS lying around. You don't have to thank us.

You know what else you can do with that extraneous Phat? Mod it without worrying that you will be left bereft of a working handheld. After all, there's always an inherent risk in modding that you will fry something or lose a tiny-yet-integral piece. But if you already have a second DS, in its Liter form, waiting for you -- then why not live the dream and create a showpiece?
Of course, this is only the tip of the iceberg, as we could go on and on about the benefits of the DS Lite. After all, we're fans. It's what we do. But it's time for those of us on the Lite side to step out of the spotlight and make way for tomorrow's counter-argument in favor of sticking with the Phat.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
7-19-2007 @ 4:44PM
Smatt said...
I know the benefits but when you live in the uk they are min approx £90 ($175) so the cost outways the benefits until i'm finished uni. And by then the DS 2 might be out anyway so unless my DS packs up I'm staying put.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 4:53PM
Nushio said...
The only way you're taking my (painted) DSPhat from me is from my cold, dead hands.
That said, I am looking for a way to get an Enamel Navy DSLite, but now that its been discontinued, I guess its just a fool's hope.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 4:59PM
Bob799 said...
I havent upgraded cause I would rather buy games than an upgrade.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 5:15PM
Herby said...
I upgraded and gave my Phat to my niece as a gift. It was well worth it. The screens are so much brighter, games like NSMB and Kirby Canvas Curse looks absolutely amazing on the Lite. The bigger stylus was a nice plus as well.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 5:19PM
Broken Gavel said...
I upgraded to a black DS lite last December. My friend came over to play some Mario Kart with his White lite and I got jealous.
The next day I made him take me to get one. It was two days after Christmas and I had to go to 7 stores before I could find one.
It was so worth it.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 5:48PM
Alisha Karabinus said...
I also covet an Enamel Navy model, Nushio, but it seems there are always other things to spend money on than a new Lite plus extra shipping and import costs... but it's really the best-looking of all the models. Sigh.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 6:21PM
Pknel said...
Number 9 is the reason I upgraded. Now I can play multiplayer games easily and I can also play games while my sisters are playing. That is, if they aren't both playing with one which happens quite often.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 8:05PM
Donald said...
I needed to pick up a 2nd DS recently and had my heart set on a Blue Phat, but couldn't find a Phat for the life of me. Ended up with a Lite.
So that would be the most important reason to go with the Lite.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 8:19PM
Kakiray said...
i didnt want to upgrade it
but i was forced to
my old delicious DSPhat was stolen (guess they cant keep their hands off of it)
so i needed to buy a new shiny black lite (damn thing is a fingerprint magnet)
I still have dreams about how my sexy Phat baby is doing right now
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 8:23PM
Alisha Karabinus said...
Man, people stealing your game gear is just wrong. My sympathies go out to you!
I didn't choose a black Lite for just that reason, though. My PSP taught me the dangers of the black electronic fingerprint magnet. White is much safer.
Or at least less visible.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 8:35PM
MAL said...
I bought a Phat DS with a warranty at EB and when I went to exchange it they were all out of Phats so it got replaced with a black DS Lite.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 8:55PM
strider_mt2k said...
I waited for the DS Lite to be out in black and then I pounced.
I see an original DS and I can't believe they are related!!
I really love my Onyx DS lite.
It's everything the article said, and the proverbial bag of chips.
Reply
7-19-2007 @ 11:26PM
Chazz said...
I still rock it out with a DS phat. I just can't bring myself to spend $130 on something I sorta own already. Especially with all the new games coming out.
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 12:47AM
JCFG said...
Im actually waiting for a price drop to upgrade. My DS phat is working fine right now.
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 3:46AM
Peppaz said...
The DS lite is the best handheld I've ever owned. I love my PSP's big screen, but my Onyx DS Lite is extremely bright, the speakers are super loud if necessary, and most importantly, its friggin slick.. The DS Phat pales in comparison to the Lite. Lites are actually even becoming a status symbol nowadays.
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 3:49AM
Grey Acumen said...
Why hasn't anyone mentioned the larger stylusthat comes with it?
Admitedly, if it's that big of an issue, most people just buy an actual pen sized stylus, but I honestly like the stylus that comes with the DS lite.
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 4:55AM
DKong said...
I switched, and I regret it.
The brighter screen is no big deal, the shiny-ness of the lite is overpowered by fingerprints, and it was a $20 setback (got 110 for my old DS and one of my games that I didn't plan on playing again)...
I also think it's uncomfortable as hell to hold. My hands really aren't that big, but for me, hitting the shoulder buttons (especially in fast paced games like Daigasso Band Brothers) is a total bitch.
I also DESPISE that the power button is on the side. How many times I've accidently powered down is beyond me.
The only things I like about my new lite is that the battery is fresh (my old DS's battery was slowly getting less and less life. I think it got down to like 6 hours of gameplay at one point) and the stylus is bigger.
If you have a DSphat in good working condition- keep it!
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 6:46AM
Protospasm said...
Jeez, I'm perfectly content with my DS-Phat (Red with checkered strap)... but the enticement intensified with point number nine.
I'm constantly wanting to 2-player someone without the system... especially when they keep trying to take mine and play it when I'm playing it.
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 8:42AM
Pete said...
Two things worth mentioning...
1. Gameboy Advance games stick out of the DSlite obnoxiously .
2. DSlite buttons are flimsy and seem to float around in their position while the DSPhat's buttons are sturdy and less prone to cramp your hand while in a desperate NSMB multiplayer battle.
Reply
7-20-2007 @ 9:12AM
ssuk said...
2 reasons why I'm sticking with the DS instead of a DSL:
Better screen quality and better speaker quality. The DSL plays Elite Beat Agents and Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan! like crap, frankly. The colours look washed out, the sound crackles and sounds muffled. It's terrible. Before I played EBA and OTO on the DSL, I was all for one... But now, I am most definatly not interested.
Reply