Seizure brought on by DS game leads to banning crusade
Posted Dec 6th 2007 8:00PM by Candace Savino
Filed under: News
After a boy in the UK fell into an epileptic fit from playing
Rayman Raving Rabbids on the DS, his mother, Gaye Herford, protested to Parliament that there should be more vigorous safety testing for video games. Should her campaign be successful, any games that could potentially cause seizures will be banned in the UK and game developers will have to adhere to stricter safety standards. Currently, thirty-five Members of Parliament stand behind the proposal.
Ubisoft (the makers of
Rabbids) responded by saying that the company already pre-screened
Rabbids DS for the potential to cause epileptic fits, and the testing showed that the game was unlikely to do so. Managing director of Ubisoft UK Robert Cooper added, however, that the company has made the decision to now test all in-house games prior to release.
[Via Pocket Gamer]
Tags: epilepsy, epileptic-fit, Health, Parliament, Politics, rabbids, rayman, rayman-raving-rabbids, Safety, seizure, Ubisoft
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-06-2007 @ 8:12PM
RupeeClock said...
Is there any actual seizure enducing scenes in the game, or was it just a poor kid who they didn't know would be vulnerable to epileptic fits?
I mean EVERY single DS game comes with epilepsy warnings.
Reply
12-06-2007 @ 8:18PM
Fiefdom said...
There are already safety warnings on game packaging and manuals for games and consoles which advise against playing any sort of video game if a child is prone to epilepsy. They also suggest that some people (from memory, I think it's one in every four thousand) may experience an epileptic fit playing games even if they've never before experienced one.
I can understand this woman being upset that her son experienced an unexpected epileptic seizure but that's no reason to try to quell an entire industry. There's a risk of fatal crashes when somebody in is a car or an airplane but that doesn't necessitate those forms of transportation being removed even though most feasible safety measures and precautions are taken as best as is realistically possible. Perhaps the public school system should be reorganized to prevent large groups of children being in a small area so as to cater to the tiny minority of students who are highly susceptible to illness. This is such a stupid and selfish plea from an emotionally distraught mother has yet to be educated on the entity which she is trying to fight against.
Reply
12-06-2007 @ 8:36PM
Blue_Falcon said...
"...any games that could potentially cause seizures will be banned in the UK..."
So basically they're saying ban every game. Since any game could cause seizures.
Reply
12-06-2007 @ 8:56PM
awesomo said...
sigh. all it takes is for one overzealous parent to spoil it for the rest of us. poor kid, but come on.
Reply
12-06-2007 @ 9:17PM
Jacob said...
If your kid breaks out into fits from video games, don't let him play video games. It isn't parliament, or any government's job for that matter, to decide what human beings can play and what they can't play. There are warnings on the box and the first window that pops up on the DS is a warning too.
Granted, games don't need to be insanely gratuitous with flashing lights and such, and then when half its player start having seizures, point to the box and say "can't touch me!", there does need to be some safety standard, but there are always going to be risks associated with any sort of device that has you staring at a screen that flashes images at you. There are risks associated with everything in life. Going on a crusade to make the government put its citizens in bubble wrap won't do any good.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 5:19AM
Matdredalia said...
I totally second this motion.
I'm sorry, but if my child was prone to epilepsy, that means no video games, no matter how badly they want them.
And if I didn't know they were prone to epilepsy, well that sure as hell isn't a video game companies fault.
12-07-2007 @ 7:42AM
ssuk said...
So wait, you'd bar your children from playing games... Which 90% of them do NOTHING to epilepsy sufferers because there's a chance she/he could play one game which uses excessive screen flashes or something which may trigger an epileptic fit? Yeah, sounds like a good idea.
12-06-2007 @ 9:50PM
Jackson H said...
Ugh. Isn't there already like 97 seizure warnings all over the DS and every single game? Someone should sue her for negligent parenting for failure to read the product warnings.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 5:26AM
velocitystrike said...
I com-frickin-pletely agree. Argh.
Maybe the boy already had freakin Epilepsy ¬_¬
12-07-2007 @ 7:45AM
ssuk said...
It's a general health and safety warning. There's usually an epilepsy warning at the front of every manual made since 1995. However, those warnings are becoming less frequent in manuals as we've learnt more about what epilepsy is and what triggers it.
Nintendo includes epilepsy by default in all manuals and the black health and safety booklets they include with every game. Doesn't mean every game will cause an epileptic fit, however.
12-06-2007 @ 10:20PM
kiev said...
i hate how this has become like her selfish and personal quest to ruin it for everybody just because she got unlucky, or rather her son did. BUt what will "more rigorous" testing do other than prolong the release of games ? I've never played raving rabbids, but im sure every game has the potential to cause seizures, and as been said 100 times before, there are warnings everywhere, most notably the startup screen. How much more clear can they get? Perhaps she's not literate along with them 35 members behind her case. IMO, this is sad news all together+ a step back for humanity. Dumb lady. She's like one of those ppl who sue the coffee shop chains for not having the "caution:hot" warning label. Hopefully she loses.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 5:15AM
2dere said...
OMG! And we should like, ban jellyfish from the sea because my little brother got stung and like There wasn't a sign in the water next to where he was swimming telling him that there is a chance it could happen....
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 7:39AM
ssuk said...
There are actually testing facilities in the UK (in Aston, Birmingham, actually) to test for seizure-threatening trends on-screen. Infact, the BBC has pointed out this many times, and has been a big debate since Megaman on the NES caused so many seizures back in the day. However, nothing has been done about making it a requirement to test for this kind of thing in any form of popular media (movies, TV Shows, games, pop videos, etc). I don't think this movement here and now will do anything more than any other complaint that's been made before.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 7:47AM
ssuk said...
Also, why is that woman standing in front of a screen of Sonic The Hedgehog (360/PS3)?
12-07-2007 @ 9:19AM
Jacky said...
I think she's just anti fun, but I've played this game and I didn't really notice any strong flashes, the only thing that happened to me was getting light headed from blowing into the mic too vigorously, may be I could sue... that info isn't on the packaging lol
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 10:04AM
TheCoats said...
OBJECTION!!
I believe there is an epilepsy warning when you first turn on the ds??.....where you have to touch the screen to make it go away??......Parents fault!!!.....
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 12:50PM
mian said...
Also, all sugar should be banned to protect diabetics. And all gluten containing products to protect celiacs. Once we start protecting people with allergies we'll make a real dent in that whole over population thing.
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 5:50PM
Benjamin L. said...
That's like banning all paper products because there's a change you MIGHT get a paper cut...
What a b!tch
Reply
12-07-2007 @ 6:09PM
Bluebreaker said...
Guys go easy on her...she felt as if she almost lost her boy. On the holidays no less. And now the poor child will proabably never go near another game (or any type of screen for that matter) again
Reply